How to pick a health plan without losing your mind


Caitlin's Corner

Sifting through Open Enrollment

Hello readers,

This may be the last time I get through to you before 2027. I hate to say this out loud, but it's the final week before our lives get completely bonkers. Susan and I will still be in your inbox, but we get it if you're feeling way too busy to keep up.

In case this is the last email of mine that you'll actually read in 2026, I want to make sure it's helpful. So,

  • First: take note of our final Wealth Wednesday of the year, which will walk you through last-minute tax checks you can take to ensure you're as squared away as possible for your 2026 taxes.
  • Then, let's make sure you're squared away for open enrollment!

This is the most common time of year for choosing health insurance and other benefits if you're employed by someone offering those benefits. If you're self employed, then you're also in the open enrollment period for marketplace healthcare coverage. This feels overwhelming, but it's important to make sure you're making the right choices, based on the knowledge you have now about your health in 2027 and beyond. That sounds ridiculous because absolutely none of us can predict what our health or that of our family members will do in the next year. But, if we have planned procedures, high-cost medications, or complications, then we have some way to inform our 2027 healthcare decisions. If not, then that itself can inform our decisions.

Choosing a Health Insurance Plan

Whether you're choosing an employer-sponsored health insurance plan or a marketplace healthcare plan, you have to decide which plan is best for you. Some of us may have a ton of choices, while some of us may have the choice of either a traditional or a high-deductible health plan, whether it's an HMO or a PPO (keep reading for an explanation of these acronyms). No matter which plans are available, you might be feeling like there's no great choice. If that's you, then you're not alone. Healthcare costs are at an all-time high, while it feels like coverage is at an all-time low. But the differences between different plan types still remain relevant. Here are two of the most commonly offered health plans:

Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) Plans

An HMO plan is when a network of doctors, specialists, and hospitals agree to provide care for a lower cost to patients covered by that plan. HMOs can be great if it's easy enough to get appointments with providers within that HMO. However, all patients in an HMO plan must have a primary care provider and they cannot go out of network if they want any coverage, unless they can prove that their out of network visit is for a life-threatening emergency. HMO plans often offer lower costs of visits and procedures to people on their plans, but a big drawback is how limiting an HMO's network might be. Kaiser is a common example of an HMO plan. If you're on an ACA Marketplace plan, there's a very good chance it's an HMO plan.

Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) Plans

These plans tend to give patients more flexibility when it comes to choosing care. Similar to HMOs, PPOs contract with a network of providers and facilities in order to offer discounted care to patients with that plan. These tend to be much broader, nationwide networks. Their costs may not be as competitive as with an HMO, but they tend to offer more coverage, and still allow patients to choose out-of-network care, where patients can still be covered by max out-of-pocket limits (which are almost always higher than the in-network max out-of-pocket limits). It's very common to see PPO plans on employer-sponsored health plans.

High-Deductible Health Plans (HDHP)

Many health plans offer a pricing variation that lowers the monthly premium that consumers have to pay for the plan, in exchange for that consumer having to pay a higher deductible for care that goes beyond preventative. You can have an HMO plan that is a high-deductible plan, or a PPO plan that is a high-deductible plan.

The Million-Dollar Question: Higher Premiums or Higher Deductibles?

The "million-dollar" part here isn't an exaggeration. Over our lifetimes, we might spend close to $1M on healthcare. We can definitely make decisions to help us curb that cost, based on what we think we can expect from our health in the coming year.

If you don't expect to need a lot of healthcare this year -> HDHP, with HSA contributions may be best

If you plan to do preventative visits only, and otherwise don't anticipate needing many procedures, expensive drugs, or specialist appointments, then a high-deductible health plan might work for you. You pay far less in monthly premiums in order to have this plan, but you only pay out of pocket when you require care beyond that. It's a gamble to make this claim, but that gamble is somewhat checked by the total out-of-pocket maximums on your plan.

One huge benefit to being enrolled in a high-deductible health plan is being able to contribute to a Health Savings Account (HSA). HSAs allow you to make pre-tax contributions to an investment account. You may have heard me talk about HSAs as the only tool that gives us a triple tax advantage. This is because we get a tax advantage when contributing (we can lower our taxable income with our HSA contributions), then we can invest our HSA funds and watch them grow tax-free, and finally when it comes time to withdraw funds from our HSA accounts and use them for qualified medical expenses, we do so without paying any tax.

The HSA Strategy

You also may have heard me talk about the HSA strategy as a way to grow tax-free wealth. If you're in a position where it makes sense to enroll in a high-deductible health plan, you have the opportunity to contribute to your HSA. In doing so, you can reduce your taxable income, and benefit from tax-free growth in your HSA account. Just like funds in a brokerage account, you can invest your HSA funds in the stock market. Year after year, you can make pre-tax contributions to your HSA account, lowering your taxable income and increasing the growth of your HSA account.

I think one of the biggest opportunities of having an HSA account is not to treat it like a healthcare checking account. Many people withdraw their HSA funds immediately for current medical expenses, missing the long-term growth opportunity. A better strategy, when possible, is to pay current medical expenses out-of-pocket, invest HSA funds for long-term growth, and save receipts. You can reimburse yourself tax-free years later while your HSA balance compounds.

If you know you'll need a lot of healthcare this year -> Traditional plan may be best

On average, traditional plans cost about $1,000 more per year in premiums than high-deductible health plans. Therefore, if you know you're likely to need at least $1,000 worth of care (beyond preventative care), then it might make sense for you to spend the extra $1,000 in annual premiums so you can have more of your health costs covered by your plan. It's important to note that you don't get to contribute to an HSA if you're not on a high-deductible health plan.

We sincerely hope that you and your loved ones stay healthy in 2027 and beyond. While we, too are frustrated by the state of healthcare in our country, we absolutely believe in being insured! May you choose your plan carefully, and hopefully you won't need to use it!


What I'm Reading

đź“• I'm bringing back this Black Friday pep-talk to my beloved readers.


Join us for free the first Wednesday of each month for an informative money conversation!

Next Up:

December 2nd, 1pm CT

​End of Year Tax Planning​

Join the last Wealth Wednesday session of 2026 so you can find out how we turn a dry topic into an interesting one! We'll give you clear, actionable steps you can take to ensure you're making the most of your 2026 taxes and beyond.


Work with Us

Women’s financial realities have historically been overlooked in traditional financial planning. We’re here to change that.

If you want help staying on track today and building for the bigger picture, schedule a call with us to get started!

Disclosure: Rising Femme Wealth, LLC is a Registered Investment Adviser. The information provided in this newsletter is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Reading this newsletter does not create an advisory relationship. All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal.

Rising Femme Wealth

Rising Femme Wealth is where life coaching for women meets financial expertise. We support motivated women on their journeys towards building financial freedom in the lives they design. Design your life and your financial plan with clarity and confidence.

Read more from Rising Femme Wealth
Office desk

Susan's Scoop When Your Career Costs Too Much Last week my husband Brian spoke at the funeral for his old boss. His boss died of a massive heart attack, despite being younger than Brian and a marathon runner, leaving behind a wife and a young son. Four years ago this month, Brian was on that same path. His team was responsible for designing new AI chips, and every step forward was something that needed to have been done yesterday to stay competitive. He started having chest pains and constant...

Caitlin's Corner Maybe It's Just Time to Be Done with Credit Card Rewards I've been on a relative bender when it comes to acquiring premium credit cards. Relative, I should say, to my own history, though certainly not relative to most of the travel rewards bloggers out there. In 2024, I got a high-fee United credit card, since I knew I'd mostly be flying United out of my new hometown. Racking up United miles became a big motivator for me, since I wanted to be able to travel more easily to...

girl with butterfly net

Susan's Scoop My Butterfly Net I had a couple of topics I was mulling over for the newsletter this week – one around an interesting quote on women and marriage from the book “Mad Mabel” (which I recently finished), and another on some financial infidelity issues a friend is going through with their partner. But both topics are somewhat incendiary – and honestly I feel like that’s the last thing we need right now with the midterm elections around the corner and everything around us, from TV to...